NDL Forum

TheGobOne wrote:

dusters06 wrote:I mentioned earlier if we could up the frequency of the hamstring strain types that force guys out for 3-5 games then I'd be all for it. It seems we either have nothing or blown ulnar radius bronchitis types...

OOTP 18 fixes this perfectly. From what I can tell there are 3 types of injuries. Minor, moderate, and severe. Minor injuries (calf strain, sore knees etc...) are things guys can play through and 95% of them will be fine after. Moderate injuries (broken finger on non-throwing hand, broken nose, etc...) can be played through but have a greater risk of turning into a severe injury. Severe injuries (Tommy John surgery, torn ligaments etc...) obviously are things that are impossible to play through.

I had an offline game where a player had a 5 month moderate injury to his shoulder. Played through it the whole year and he was fine. His numbers were down obviously but he never made a DL trip.

This isn't an endorsement to move to '18. I'm just saying when we move to '19 this injury system (which I love) should still be a feature.

TheGobOne wrote:

dusters06 wrote:I mentioned earlier if we could up the frequency of the hamstring strain types that force guys out for 3-5 games then I'd be all for it. It seems we either have nothing or blown ulnar radius bronchitis types...

OOTP 18 fixes this perfectly. From what I can tell there are 3 types of injuries. Minor, moderate, and severe. Minor injuries (calf strain, sore knees etc...) are things guys can play through and 95% of them will be fine after. Moderate injuries (broken finger on non-throwing hand, broken nose, etc...) can be played through but have a greater risk of turning into a severe injury. Severe injuries (Tommy John surgery, torn ligaments etc...) obviously are things that are impossible to play through.

I had an offline game where a player had a 5 month moderate injury to his shoulder. Played through it the whole year and he was fine. His numbers were down obviously but he never made a DL trip.

This isn't an endorsement to move to '18. I'm just saying when we move to '19 this injury system (which I love) should still be a feature.

shel311 wrote:Just to keep track of all pending items:

- Move to '18
- Sim 7 days per week
- Find a replacement for Dak



Anything I missed?

Wasted Memory wrote:Oh, you also forgot the stats lab draft thingy

Cnasty wrote:-Train GoBoner on how to do 12 hour rollovers

Uuaww wrote:Expect a week rollover if he loses to shel after being up 3-1.

Cnasty wrote:

Uuaww wrote:Expect a week rollover if he loses to shel after being up 3-1.

We would go to '18 because '17 would definitely be broken if this happened.

shel311 wrote:

Cnasty wrote:17-2 was the vote in favor of not raising the injury level. Just a reminder.

I was one of the 2 and I am assuming Ted was the other (poll creator).

I was a not vote due to insufficient information on the comparison to real life.

No graphs = no vote

Uuaww wrote:

TheGobOne wrote:

dusters06 wrote:I mentioned earlier if we could up the frequency of the hamstring strain types that force guys out for 3-5 games then I'd be all for it. It seems we either have nothing or blown ulnar radius bronchitis types...

OOTP 18 fixes this perfectly. From what I can tell there are 3 types of injuries. Minor, moderate, and severe. Minor injuries (calf strain, sore knees etc...) are things guys can play through and 95% of them will be fine after. Moderate injuries (broken finger on non-throwing hand, broken nose, etc...) can be played through but have a greater risk of turning into a severe injury. Severe injuries (Tommy John surgery, torn ligaments etc...) obviously are things that are impossible to play through.

I had an offline game where a player had a 5 month moderate injury to his shoulder. Played through it the whole year and he was fine. His numbers were down obviously but he never made a DL trip.

This isn't an endorsement to move to '18. I'm just saying when we move to '19 this injury system (which I love) should still be a feature.

how much is 18? if moving solves our issues... I mean, why not? we are all adults with real jobs!

dusters06 wrote:Why are you yelling?