NFL Thread

[shel311]

That's the romo we know and love!!

I understand this. I really do.

I don't.

If I'm not mistaken, he leads all QBs in 4th quarter QB Rating and also in 4th quarter comeback wins since he's been a starter, or something along those lines.

I know he botched 1 snap at a really bad time lol. But otherwise, his rep as the choke artist seems way off base.

yeah

I've always thought the guy was really good

I've said for years that he is rather easily the most underrated player in the NFL. I'd imagine if you search my posts, I've posted it a few times lol.

He's not top tier worthy(Manning/Brees/Rodgers/Brady), but he's basically at the top of the next teir, whatever that may be.

[Cnasty]

I am not saying he isnt a good QB, he is.

But lets not act like his performances at big levels arent mediocre at best.

Throw for 9000 yards and 80 tds but get to the playoffs against tougher teams and have 4 performances that he has shows some merit that he isnt all that on a bigger stage, no?

4 games not enough?

I will say he hasnt had another shot since 2009 and thats not his fault and has definitely improved since then.

[nick]

500 yards passing and 5 touchdowns is mediocre

[Cnasty]

500 yards passing and 5 touchdowns is mediocre

He did that in the playoffs? I must have missed that in the link.

[shel311]

4 games not enough?

Nope

But to my greater point, if he leads the team down the field for the win instead of the INT, no one is backtracking off of their "Romo is a choker stance".

So the whole idea is dumb if he can only be a choker, but not be clutch. That's what I'm getting at.

[nick]

Peyton Mannings career playoff record is 9-11 and he threw a pick last yr in OT to lose to Baltimore. guess by your thinking hes a mediocre QB too...

[ChampDizzle]

I am 99.9% bias against Romo...........Go Skins!

[Cnasty]

Cant say no one, but you can say the media wouldnt.

I would have given him some credit as he has been looking like a top 5 QB all season and has always been good in my eyes.

But if you are watching that, most people were thinking "when is the romo moment?" and there it was solidifying the moment. (Saw 5 posts about it on FB but thats more to your point I guess )

I think 4 NFL playoffs games is a pretty good sample size in comparisons to other sports.

[Cnasty]

Peyton Mannings career playoff record is 9-11 and he threw a pick last yr in OT to lose to Baltimore. guess by your thinking hes a mediocre QB too...

Go away

[ajalves]

Go Skins!

speaking of a trainwreck

[nick]

Go Skins!

speaking of a trainwreck

thankfully the rams got their 1st... which wont matter since this team just blows

[ChampDizzle]

Go Skins!

speaking of a trainwreck

with no survivors I thought defense would be better but I was wrong. But only half game out of first

[ChampDizzle]

Go Skins!

speaking of a trainwreck

thankfully the rams got their 1st... which wont matter since this team just blows

helped me in uuaw survivor

[ajalves]

Go Skins!

speaking of a trainwreck

with no survivors I thought defense would be better but I was wrong. But only half game out of first

I think they need to dump Deangelo Hall. Trade him for some picks.

They need a legit reciever or 2 as well.

[shel311]

But if you are watching that, most people were thinking "when is the romo moment?" and there it was solidifying the moment. (Saw 5 posts about it on FB but thats more to your point I guess )

Pretty much

[nick]

Tony Romo is the only QB in NFL history to lose a game with a +140 QB rating with a minimum of 30 attempts.

And last night was the 2nd time in his career it happened

[ajalves]

Tony Romo is the only QB in NFL history to lose a game with a +140 QB rating with a minimum of 30 attempts.

And last night was the 2nd time in his career it happened

the question really is, how many current QBs are better

[shel311]

Tony Romo is the only QB in NFL history to lose a game with a +140 QB rating with a minimum of 30 attempts.

And last night was the 2nd time in his career it happened

the question really is, how many current QBs are better

Playing the "1 game for my life" game, I see only 5 I'd take over him.

But then, there's a couple more who are very similar.


The 5 being the Big 4 plus Rivers.

[ajalves]

Tony Romo is the only QB in NFL history to lose a game with a +140 QB rating with a minimum of 30 attempts.

And last night was the 2nd time in his career it happened

the question really is, how many current QBs are better

Playing the "1 game for my life" game, I see only 5 I'd take over him.

But then, there's a couple more who are very similar.


The 5 being the Big 4 plus Rivers.

no Luck? No Ryan?

just curious

[shel311]

Honestly, Luck/Ryan/STafford were the 3 who I thought were similar. Could go either way on all 4 of those guys, but Romo would be 1st or 2nd on that list for me.