NDL Forum

Sheltown rotation: leaps and bounds better than Richmond
Richmond's lineup: better than Sheltown's

Richmond: shit division
Sheltown: best division in baseball top to bottom

Overall edge: Sheltown

Wasted Memory wrote:

wdoupis wrote:You crazy kids will say anything. Sheltown is not better than Richmond with or without Todd although it is much much closer than when he made these declarations in previos seasons

It's so hard to take you seriously any more.

Its like watching Feistygator in his hey day with his homerism. (old NDL NCAA reference)

Wasted Memory wrote:

wdoupis wrote:You crazy kids will say anything. Sheltown is not better than Richmond with or without Todd although it is much much closer than when he made these declarations in previos seasons

It's so hard to take you seriously any more.

Pretty sure Billy is the only one who'd think Richmond is better if both squads were healthy.

He's Jsence level biased towards his team.

Cnasty wrote:
Its like watching Feistygator in his hey day with his homerism. (old NDL NCAA reference)

You probably don't remember this Corey, but I was in the NDL back when the PS2 was still the main console. Used the name Gator Bytes then though. Dropped out after the PS3 came out. I choose to go XBox, came back a year or so later but changed to my current name.

Any way, yeah I remember

Because I said I am better than Sheltown? That is not even a bold stance there buddy

I do remember.

I think you also ran your own league for a while with Bama, Ank, and some other NDL guys. I was part of that league for a while.

Unless that is another Gator fan.

wdoupis wrote:Because I said I am better than Sheltown? That is not even a bold stance there buddy

With a healthy toss, it's very bold.

I was in that league, but it was a different guy running it. G8r? G8rfan? Something like that.

Wasted Memory wrote:I was in that league, but it was a different guy running it. G8r? G8rfan? Something like that.

Haha, yup i think you are right.

Cnasty wrote:Sheltown rotation: leaps and bounds better than Richmond

That makes no sense. Bryan and McGuire are not better than Reyes and Noda. The rotations are both really good and a push.

My edge on offense is difference.

wdoupis wrote:The rotations are both really good and a push.

shel311 wrote:

wdoupis wrote:The rotations are both really good and a push.

Explain what’s funny?

wdoupis wrote:

Cnasty wrote:Sheltown rotation: leaps and bounds better than Richmond

The rotations are both really good and a push.

wdoupis wrote:

shel311 wrote:

wdoupis wrote:The rotations are both really good and a push.

Explain what’s funny?

I believe he's saying he thinks it's funny you think your rotation is as good as his. Maybe I'm misinterpreting it though...

I know but that is what he always does. He never really has a reason or explains it. We literally had the same exact argument last season with same rotations and they basically proved to be a push last year and this year as well.

Somehow that still means his is way better

wdoupis wrote:I know but that is what he always does. He never really has a reason or explains it.

This is my favorite part of the Billy debate, especially with pitchers.


He wants you to explain it, but he thinks using overall rating, WAR, ERA, and FIP are all useless for SPs, so it's his sneaky way of being able to say his pitchers are just as good "just cause" with no real reason, while telling me I have no real reason to say mine are better.



Billy, would you like for me to post a comparison of ERA, WAR, and FIP? Would that help "explain it?"





Immersion topic - Activated

I'll just go ahead and do it:

Starter ERA

SHL - 2.98, 1st in AL
RICH - 3.88, 4th in AL

Advantage: SHL

FIP of top 5 starters

SHL

1.82
2.75
2.83
3.60
5.13

RICH

2.99
3.58
3.67
3.91
4.42

Advantage SHL


Starter WAR

SHL

3.2
2.1
1.8
1.3
0.0

RICH

1.6
1.2
1.1
0.9
0.4

Advantage SHL





But it's a PUSH....just cause!!!

But...but...he has the better record!

Billy says a lot of things.

shel311 wrote:I'll just go ahead and do it:

Starter ERA

SHL - 2.98, 1st in AL
RICH - 3.88, 4th in AL

Advantage: SHL

FIP of top 5 starters

SHL

1.82
2.75
2.83
3.60
5.13

RICH

2.99
3.58
3.67
3.91
4.42

Advantage SHL


Starter WAR

SHL

3.2
2.1
1.8
1.3
0.0

RICH

1.6
1.2
1.1
0.9
0.4

Advantage SHL





But it's a PUSH....just cause!!!

Great breakdown Shel and yeah, looks like a push to me!