NDL Forum

Taking Shel's advice, I shortened the time needed to be eligible to one year since these guys won't be unretiring. Still, the list is fairly barebones. Remember, this is the HALL OF FAME and not the All-Star Game, so do show some consideration when voting.

Yes, I cleared your old votes.

http://ndlbaseball.com/StatsLab/hall_of_fame_vote.php

Notable Players Eligible

SP Pedro Enriquez (New England)

2011 Tom Seaver Trophy Winner, 2011 Atlantic League Morris Playoff MVP winner, two-time All-Star, and one of only seven pitchers in win 20 games and the second player to do so.

Career Metrics
Black Ink 6
Gray Ink 63

SP Alex Thomas (New York)

2010 All-Star, holds all-time record for complete games in a season (14)

Career Metrics
Black Ink: 17
Gray Ink: 69

SP Jason Stillwell (New York)

2010 Atlantic League Morris Playoff MVP winner and pretty much known only for that amazing run in the 2010 playoffs.

Career Metrics
Black Ink: 0
Gray Ink: 2

RP Rob Towns (New England)

2010 Tom Seaver Trophy winner, three-time All-Star, and - if eligible, would have the third-lowest ERA in NDLB history.

What is Black/Gray Ink?

MLB Black Ink Average HOFer = 40
MLB Grey Ink Average HOFer = 185

2 Questions,

1- What is the criteria to get in? 15 votes?

2- Do these guys stay on the ballot next year? I have 1 borderline guy that I don't want to put in on first ballot

Its tough too because we dont have anyone to compare to of recent invitees.

When we vote we are setting the bar of who we let in going forward and current guys are already doing better than these guys I believe.

Tough vote!

Can new guys opt out of the voting since I don't even know what a good season is yet?

trendon wrote:Taking Shel's advice

Smart man.

Bernie32 wrote:2- Do these guys stay on the ballot next year? I have 1 borderline guy that I don't want to put in on first ballot

I think guys should stay on for 3 seasons, and that's it. Just my take.




2 really solid players. This is really tough being so new to the league that some guys, while top 5 at their position, really only have 3-4 seasons under their belts.

East Coast bias strikes OOTP Hall of Fame vote list.

None are "Hall of Fame" worthy, though.

Bernie32 wrote:2 Questions,

1- What is the criteria to get in? 15 votes?

2- Do these guys stay on the ballot next year? I have 1 borderline guy that I don't want to put in on first ballot

1. 75% and we have 19 voters. That is 14.25, but I don't know how the utility handles decimals.
2. Five percent (one vote) to stay on the ballot.

cougnix wrote:Can new guys opt out of the voting since I don't even know what a good season is yet?

Just submit a blank ballot.

trendon wrote:

cougnix wrote:Can new guys opt out of the voting since I don't even know what a good season is yet?

Just submit a blank ballot.

Won't let me login. I am using the same login I use for the game, but says the password is wrong.

baseball is the default password for StatsLab

I dont see myself voting anyone into the HOF for a good 5-10 seasons. You need a career's worth of stats to get in, imo. These dudes retiring 3-5 yrs in wont have stats thta players like Hays, Flores, Ladd, Murphy among others will have.

If that is the case, please submit a blank ballot. It is important.

first Toronto player to get into HOF will have his # retired