cnotes008 wrote:I did talk to someone after a game about a problem i had. they commented on my reports that a played a straight game, then bashed me on points. Guess i should have kept my mouth shut!
it isnt possible for you guys to know who "bashed" you in the reports. This isnt directed at you Cnotes, but everyone. Several people have said they told me one theing then docked my points. How do you know WHO docked your points?
One of the biggest problems with coaches reports is people saying one thing and then doing another....
another is the point deductions and then no comments at all
yet another is the "all 5's"in comments when thats not what they gave.
then there are the guys who bash guys for things they didnt do
then guys like guys who get on their opponents because they were "bored" or their opponent didnt "entertain" them
This thread is fine for now and lets keep it that way to save Buckeye the headache. However, if you're guilty of any of the things I listed above, then that stinks
Thats not the intention of the coaches reports. I am not say you should be giving all 5s, score how you see fit. just do it like an adult please
how misleading you dick! I write "5/5 - Nick" if I give a 5 and I don't have much to say to the person/not close enough I can make fun of them on the CR.
AJ when we play I'll give you a 10/5 so you can get those points back
nick wrote:
how misleading you dick! I write "5/5 - Nick" if I give a 5 and I don't have much to say to the person/not close enough I can make fun of them on the CR.
AJ when we play I'll give you a 10/5 so you can get those points back
nick wrote:
how misleading you dick! I write "5/5 - Nick" if I give a 5 and I don't have much to say to the person/not close enough I can make fun of them on the CR.
AJ when we play I'll give you a 10/5 so you can get those points back
nick wrote:
how misleading you dick! I write "5/5 - Nick" if I give a 5 and I don't have much to say to the person/not close enough I can make fun of them on the CR.
AJ when we play I'll give you a 10/5 so you can get those points back
nick wrote:
how misleading you dick! I write "5/5 - Nick" if I give a 5 and I don't have much to say to the person/not close enough I can make fun of them on the CR.
AJ when we play I'll give you a 10/5 so you can get those points back
im lost. no idea what this means
fuck it
if you give 5/5 and write in comments "5/5 Nick"
then there is zero wrong with that
im just saying, now people who for whatever reason have less than 100, see my comment, are now gonna think I docked them like a dick lol.
if I have a major problem I would tell them and usually would not dock. It is worse not to say something. Give the coach time to correct it for future games. We should be helping not hurting. Sometimes we don't realize any questionable gameplay.
cnotes008 wrote:I did talk to someone after a game about a problem i had. they commented on my reports that a played a straight game, then bashed me on points. Guess i should have kept my mouth shut!
it isnt possible for you guys to know who "bashed" you in the points. This isnt directed at you Cnotes, but everyone. Several people have said they told me one theing then docked my points. How do you know WHO docked your points?
One of the biggest problems with coaches reports is people saying one thing and then doing another....
another is the point deductions and then no comments at all
yet another is the "all 5's"in comments when thats not what they gave.
then there are the guys who bash guys for things they didnt do
then guys who get on their opponents because they were "bored" or their opponent didnt "entertain" them
This thread is fine for now and lets keep it that way to save Buckeye the headache. However, if you're guilty of any of the things I listed above, then that stinks
Thats not the intention of the coaches reports. I am not say you should be giving all 5s, score how you see fit. just do it like an adult please
I see what you mean aj, but since I had a slacker season with connection issues and only played 4 games, I do know who did it. Its fine and I would never call them out or even try to tell, but I am sure of the person
cnotes008 wrote:
I see what you mean aj, but since I had a slacker season with connection issues and only played 4 games, I do know who did it. Its fine and I would never call them out or even try to tell, but I am sure of the person
I have a problem with someone docking me because I AIM'd them after the game and commented on their game play. And yes it actually says that in my comments that he was docking for it. Guys wonder why coaches just say "GG" afterwards and then nail them on coaches reports. Its because of this reason. I only AIM'd two guys all season and had conversations about the game and the other coach and I came to an agreement on one conversation and the other apparently decided to lower my coaches reports because I said something. Unless you are someone I play all the time or know well. Expect me to say "GG" from now on and Ill let you read what I really think a month later when your reports come out.
WJ5811 wrote:I have a problem with someone docking me because I AIM'd them after the game and commented on their game play. And yes it actually says that in my comments that he was docking for it. Guys wonder why coaches just say "GG" afterwards and then nail them on coaches reports. Its because of this reason. I only AIM'd two guys all season and had conversations about the game and the other coach and I came to an agreement on one conversation and the other apparently decided to lower my coaches reports because I said something. Unless you are someone I play all the time or know well. Expect me to say "GG" from now on and Ill let you read what I really think a month later when your reports come out.
as long as your scores given pretty much mach your CR comments, then tell them whatever you want on AIM as far as i am concerned
WJ5811 wrote:I have a problem with someone docking me because I AIM'd them after the game and commented on their game play. And yes it actually says that in my comments that he was docking for it. Guys wonder why coaches just say "GG" afterwards and then nail them on coaches reports. Its because of this reason. I only AIM'd two guys all season and had conversations about the game and the other coach and I came to an agreement on one conversation and the other apparently decided to lower my coaches reports because I said something. Unless you are someone I play all the time or know well. Expect me to say "GG" from now on and Ill let you read what I really think a month later when your reports come out.
as long as your scores given pretty much mach your CR comments, then tell them whatever you want on AIM as far as i am concerned
ChampDizzle wrote:if I have a major problem I would tell them and usually would not dock. It is worse not to say something. Give the coach time to correct it for future games. We should be helping not hurting. Sometimes we don't realize any questionable gameplay.
Spot on Champ. I remember a few seasons back when I had PSU, you told me some things after the game that you didn't like (I don't think I even realized I was doing it, whatever it was, if I remember right), not sure if you docked me or not. Don't care. It was the fact that you told me and it gave me the chance to fix it for the remainder of my games. When you did that, I immediately told myself that you were the kind of coach I wanted to play, because you were up front about the issue that you had. Huge respect for that.
WJ5811 wrote:I have a problem with someone docking me because I AIM'd them after the game and commented on their game play. And yes it actually says that in my comments that he was docking for it. Guys wonder why coaches just say "GG" afterwards and then nail them on coaches reports. Its because of this reason. I only AIM'd two guys all season and had conversations about the game and the other coach and I came to an agreement on one conversation and the other apparently decided to lower my coaches reports because I said something. Unless you are someone I play all the time or know well. Expect me to say "GG" from now on and Ill let you read what I really think a month later when your reports come out.
as long as your scores given pretty much mach your CR comments, then tell them whatever you want on AIM as far as i am concerned
I agree with that, however that wasn't my point.
That really sucks WJ. I see your point and I guess it works both ways. If guys do all of the things that AJ mentioned, then I'm sure this is a feasible scenario to. All this talk kind of sucks to hear about. Can't believe guys would do these things. Man up and play the game and don't be two faced. This isn't that complicated.
I think I'll have to create the NBS (No Bullshit) Club. We'll just adhere to our own policies... you play straight, you don't cheese, if someone questions something, you address it respectfully and then we all get 25/25! At the end of the season, if anyone doesn't have a perfect report, you get booted from the club!
I think a problem that may exist in some coaches is that we have rules for sportsmanship aimed at if a coach is winning and not rules aimed at coaches that are losing. I lost 7 games this year and out of these losses I only had one real issue with one game. I gave 5 of those teams I lost to all 5's and it was because they were good wins. Did they run stuff that I didnt like? sure. Did they run some questionable calls? sure, but the main thing is that theyre not so pickup game you would find in the lobby. I think some of us need to learn how to lose with some class and not dock guys because theyre good at passing or running or whatever.
WJ5811 wrote:I have a problem with someone docking me because I AIM'd them after the game and commented on their game play. And yes it actually says that in my comments that he was docking for it. Guys wonder why coaches just say "GG" afterwards and then nail them on coaches reports. Its because of this reason. I only AIM'd two guys all season and had conversations about the game and the other coach and I came to an agreement on one conversation and the other apparently decided to lower my coaches reports because I said something. Unless you are someone I play all the time or know well. Expect me to say "GG" from now on and Ill let you read what I really think a month later when your reports come out.
as long as your scores given pretty much mach your CR comments, then tell them whatever you want on AIM as far as i am concerned
I agree with that, however that wasn't my point.
That really sucks WJ. I see your point and I guess it works both ways. If guys do all of the things that AJ mentioned, then I'm sure this is a feasible scenario to. All this talk kind of sucks to hear about. Can't believe guys would do these things. Man up and play the game and don't be two faced. This isn't that complicated.
I think I'll have to create the NBS (No Bullshit) Club. We'll just adhere to our own policies... you play straight, you don't cheese, if someone questions something, you address it respectfully and then we all get 25/25! At the end of the season, if anyone doesn't have a perfect report, you get booted from the club!
Hey regin I think thats why some guys play the same ooc games every year. If so I know I have scrimmed alot of you guys, hit me up with some OOC requests next year I still got my bruins and would love to play you guys again, especially you reign!
P.S. that not because I know I would win, but we would battle and have a good game!
cnotes008 wrote:I did talk to someone after a game about a problem i had. they commented on my reports that a played a straight game, then bashed me on points. Guess i should have kept my mouth shut!
it isnt possible for you guys to know who "bashed" you in the points. This isnt directed at you Cnotes, but everyone. Several people have said they told me one theing then docked my points. How do you know WHO docked your points?
One of the biggest problems with coaches reports is people saying one thing and then doing another....
another is the point deductions and then no comments at all
yet another is the "all 5's"in comments when thats not what they gave.
then there are the guys who bash guys for things they didnt do
then guys who get on their opponents because they were "bored" or their opponent didnt "entertain" them
This thread is fine for now and lets keep it that way to save Buckeye the headache. However, if you're guilty of any of the things I listed above, then that stinks
Thats not the intention of the coaches reports. I am not say you should be giving all 5s, score how you see fit. just do it like an adult please
This is why I like playing in a conference or scheduling guys I know. Hell sometimes I worry about winning a game when its against a better team out of fear of being docked for some insane reason only for it to boil down to winning with a team that shouldn't have won. I personally look at everything a person does while playing but can't say I've played many that I didn't give 5's to. Even guys I haven't played before and got thrashed this past season it was good games and nothing unsim about it. They all deserved the 5's I gave them. But at the same time they gave great critiques after the game and in the comments. I'm not perfect and I honestly don't believe anyone is. We all may hit a slump and it might be calling a cover 2 man we like because of the situation or a certain play we run on D every 3rd down because it's safe. Yes we should mix it up but even when I played at the U of MN or Def Coor called the same two 3rd down plays if it was 8 to 10 yards or more for the first. What determined which he would choose would be which side of the 50 we were on lol. I'll admit I probably could mix up my defensive play calling on 3rd downs because I normally go for what I think are safe plays because I like playing man a lot lol. But we as coaches need to open our eyes a bit. There are some plays on offense and defense that call for the players to actually do something and its not the actual coach. Case in point the bump and run for DB's. I have found that there are a lot of cover 1 plays that actually press the WR's. I didn't know this myself until I played a friend and he pointed out the BNR and I saw that it was a press.
We all would like to think of ourselves as simulation players, and I believe we all are. I find it to be a difference if a coach does one thing or something that can be fixed based on a conversation, and if they are purposely trying to abuse something in the game. I have just found it harder and harder to dock people for things personally because I have had the pleasure of playing against some great competition. I don't use the strategy things but I don't dock for strategy points obtained because if you happend to use a set up play I pay attention to that and there is nothing wrong with that in my book it's realistic. No different then calling PA after successful runs. But having the DLine set to aggressive to jump the snap as you control your LB or Safeties on the other hand is a different story lol. Okay Im rambling now. I'm pleased with my points and I know I can do better. Nothing saying how I faired but I know I'm a sim coach and make mistakes or overlook something and remember we are all different what may or may not be okay to us my be perceived differently by another. So I'm very big on talking after my games or during because to me if there is something that can be corrected I would rather approach it then in hopes that it helps because not telling that coach will only hurt them in the long run where they could have fixed any possible problem instead of repeating it with another and hurting their growth process in the league. Just my opinion
